|
The Scientist: NewsBlog:
High risk NIH grants announced
Posted by Jennifer Evans [Entry posted at 22nd September 2008 02:55 PM GMT]
Rate this article
High risk but not transformative by DAVID RAY [Comment posted 2008-09-24 04:48:36] This scheme to support young researchers is to be commended. NIH is right to recognise that the heavy hand of peer review has come to limit the scope of what scientists starting their careers can achieve, especially when overall funding is tight. But in supporting high risk derivative research of the type exemplified here NIH has not fully heeded the Wizard?s warning (The Scientist 25 August 2004). In describing these research projects as derivative I do not intend to be pejorative. They represent imaginative mainstream proposals. But they are founded in our current understanding and to describe them as potentially transformative is misleading or complacent, perhaps dangerously so. Why: because we risk being side tracked from addressing seriously the current dearth of transformative research. The loss of our intellectual seed corn is highlighted by Don Braben in his excellent book Scientific Freedom: The Elixir of Civilization. Thank you by anonymous poster [Comment posted 2008-09-23 16:51:58] Thank you very much for incorporating the link. Complete List of Winners by Jennifer Evans [Comment posted 2008-09-22 14:31:53] Thank you for your comment. I've added links to the complete lists of the 2008 NIH Director's Pioneer and New Innovator Award winners. why not publish the complete list of winners? by anonymous poster [Comment posted 2008-09-22 13:09:39] I would be very interested to see the complete list of winners. Why just select a couple to highlight? Why not list them all? Comment on this blog |