|
The Scientist: NewsBlog:
A flashy defense
Posted by Megan Scudellari [Entry posted at 10th September 2008 01:09 PM GMT]
Rate this article
Reply to Kastberger by Ram Sihag [Comment posted 2008-10-15 01:30:58] Dear Kastberger
You have admitted that the behaviour is known.That corroborates my views and perhapes is a sufficient explanation.What else would you like to tell, you are always welcome. My E-mail :sihagrc@rediffmail.com The behaviour is, of course, well known, but the findings are brand new by Gerald Kastberger [Comment posted 2008-10-02 11:11:15] Dear Ram Sihag
You have delivered some opposing remarks. Would you please contact me personally by email? I am afraid I was not able to look you up in the Internet. I would like to explain to you what the new and fascinating finding of the article in PLoS ONE was. I assume that you have not at all read my research article, even not the introduction and discussion parts, otherwise you would have commented the article on a more realistic basis and in a more friendly way. Regards Gerald Kastberger To Megan Scudellari by Ruth Rosin [Comment posted 2008-09-15 21:12:50] Thanks for answeing my duestion! Already known fact by Ram Sihag [Comment posted 2008-09-15 00:39:03] The shimmering behaviour of the giant honeybee team in the colony when a wasp predator approches is already known to the global Apidology Community.Since 1998 or even befopre that,such a video has been shown in several international conferences by Professor Woyke and Niko Koeniger.This behaviour could even be replicated by other physical disturbances.There is nothing knew in the study except the statistical analysis of the data(?). Nice article by Donald Duck [Comment posted 2008-09-13 19:09:00] Anyone who reads this magazine expecting to find "hard science" is an idiot. Sign up for a real science magazine. This is the "National Inquirer", for those of us who read light material for fun, not "The Wall Street Journal".
Personally, I like the Scientist because I DON'T study bees, sharks, etc. I find the occasional interesting tidbit and look it up on wikipedia later. For me, this was new information. Love this magazine for what it is, or love an in-depth, subscription magazine. If you are serious, leave. If you are ready to relax and/or argue with me, I can honestly say you are welcome here. RE: Question by Megan Scudellari [Comment posted 2008-09-11 09:01:10] Hi Ruth,
When I spoke with Dr. Kastberger, he said he easily provokes shimmering behavior when approaching a Giant honeybee colony, and other mammals and birds cause the behavior as well. However, one of the reasons he did the study was because shimmering seemed to be especially provoked by wasps. Thanks for the question. Megan Scudellari Editorial Intern The Scientist same old, same old... by anonymous poster [Comment posted 2008-09-11 05:32:15] Hardly novel is it? Anyone who has ever studied giant honeybees knew this already. Its just a case of a flashy analysis catching the eye of an editor at a 'good' publication, who was looking for a bit of dumb media attention. All spin and nothing new... as usual. Scientific publishing just gets dumber and dumber. This doesn't interest anyone, it just ends up as filler in the press and low grade tv. Is it any wonder that the public moan about the money wasted on science funding? What happened to the big ideas? Given our current predicament, all science funding should be invested in solving the world's problems. Lets hope the engineers are on the ball because science won't save us (and all other animals) from extinction. Nice article by Pradeep K Srivastava [Comment posted 2008-09-10 23:32:54] I really enjoyed this wonedrful story about defense mechanism of honey bee. Impressive information. As seen on TV by Jack Woodall [Comment posted 2008-09-10 20:49:04] The "wave" was shown impressively on metre-wide honeycombs covered with bees on cliffs in Nepal, in a BBC documentary last August. Check it out at LINK click on the photo to enlarge it. Question by Ruth Rosin [Comment posted 2008-09-10 19:44:23] Do the giant honeybees respond with a "shimmering" only to approaching wasps? Comment on this blog |