The Mendel-Nageli letters, circa 1866-73


Samples of the correspondence
Courtesy of the Mendelianum, Brno, Czech Republic.

On New Year's Eve, 1866, Gregor Mendel wrote to the prominent Swiss botanist Carl Nägeli to tell him about his now classic experiments with Pisum peas. In the margins of the letter, Nägeli scribbled a note: "only empirical and not rational." Two months later, Nägeli wrote back to Mendel, stating, "It seems to me that the experiments with Pisum, far from being finished, are only a beginning."

Those letters were also the beginning of an eight-year correspondence, from 1866 to 1873, between the two men. Mendel only published two papers on plant hybridization in his lifetime - in 1866 and 1870. These 10 letters to Nägeli, however, cover a much wider range of Mendel's experimental work, and reveal the breadth and depth of his scientific intellect.

In a letter dated July 3, 1870, Mendel wrote: "[T]he view of Naudin and Darwin [is] that a single pollen-grain is not sufficient for an adequate fertilization of an egg... the result of my experiment, however, is an entirely different one." Using the common garden variety four-o'clock flower, Mendel was the first to show that only one pollen-grain was, indeed, sufficient for fertilization.

Courtesy of the Mendelianum, Brno, Czech Republic.
Courtesy of the Mendelianum, Brno, Czech Republic.


Advertisement


 

Rate this article

Rating: 3.75/5 (32 votes )





available in English translation
by WILLIAM PROVINE

[Comment posted 2008-08-13 12:45:05]
Dear Elie Dolgin,

The letters of Gregor Mendel to Carl Naegeli are all available in an excellent translation in Curt Stern and Eva Sherwood, eds, The Origin of Genetics: A Mendel Source Book (W. H. Freeman, San Francisco, 1966.

Best wishes, Will Provine






Front Cover

Register for FREE Online Access

  • »Current issue
  • »Best Places to Work and Salary surveys
  • »Daily news and monthly contents emails

Register »

Subscribe to the Magazine

  • »Monthly print issues
  • »Unlimited online access
  • »Special offers on books, apparel, and more

Subscribe »

Library Subscriptions
Recommend to a Librarian

Masthead | Contact | Advertise | Privacy Policy
© 1986-2012 The Scientist